Capital Vol. 1, Ch. 14 — mind map
Text version — the same content in reading order
Economic Manuscripts: Capital Vol. I - Chapter Fourteen — marxists.org
Capital Vol. I : Chapter Fourteen (Division of Labour and Manufacture)
Ch. 14 — The Division of Labour and Manufacture
The second form of relative surplus-value, and the first that changes the labour process itself. Co-operation gathered whole craftsmen under one roof. Manufacture breaks the craft into pieces and gives each piece to a different worker for life — the manufacturing period, roughly 1550 to 1770, from which the factory will emerge.
1. The dual origin of manufacture
Manufacture arises in two opposite ways, and the two arrive at the same place.
From different crafts. A carriage passes through the hands of wheelwright, harness-maker, tailor, locksmith, upholsterer. Gather them in one workshop under one capital and each soon does only carriage-work; the wheelwright who once made all wheels now makes only carriage wheels. Independent crafts become detail operations of a single product.
From one craft. Take twenty needle-makers who each made whole needles. Divide the work so that one draws the wire, one straightens it, one cuts, one points — and the single craft decomposes into detail operations, each fixed to a worker.
Either way: a productive mechanism whose organs are human beings, still resting on handicraft skill — the tool is in the hand, the hand is the basis.
2. The specialized worker
A worker who performs one operation for life becomes quicker and surer at it than the craftsman who performs twenty in turn. Repetition perfects the movement; changing from task to task, tool to tool, place to place, is eliminated — the pores of the working day are closed, and labour becomes more intense as well as more skilled. Experience accumulates and is handed down.
A worker who performs one and the same simple operation for the whole of his life converts his body into the automatic, one-sided implement of that operation.
The gain is real, and it is bought at a price the chapter will name in its last section.
…and his tools
One worker, one operation — so one tool, fitted to that operation alone. Manufacture differentiates tools: Birmingham produced some five hundred varieties of hammer, each for a single use. Tools are simplified, improved, multiplied, each adapted to the exclusive special function of the detail worker.
This is the material precondition of what comes next. A machine is a combination of simple instruments — and manufacture is what produced the simple instruments to be combined.
3. Two fundamental forms — heterogeneous and organic
Heterogeneous manufacture assembles a product from parts made independently. The watch: dozens of detail workers — spring-maker, dial-maker, hand-maker, escapement-maker, finisher — many of them at home, the parts collected and fitted by the repasseur. The workers need not even be in one building.
Organic manufacture passes the product through a connected series of processes: the needle through seventy-two hands, paper from rag to sheet. Here the detail workers are arranged in sequence, each supplying the next, and the whole becomes one living mechanism — the collective worker, of which the individuals are only organs.
The organic form is where manufacture’s own laws appear.
Proportion, and the hierarchy of labour-powers
Since each step feeds the next, each must be completed in a given time — and so there must be a definite ratio between the numbers employed at each: so many founders to so many breakers to so many rubbers in the type-foundry. The group in its fixed proportions becomes the unit; to expand, capital adds whole multiples of it. The scale of production acquires a technical law, and with it a rising minimum capital.
Different operations need different degrees of skill, so manufacture builds a hierarchy of labour-powers with a hierarchy of wages. Its novelty is at the bottom: it creates a class of unskilled workers, which the handicraft had strictly excluded. And by narrowing each skill it cuts the cost of training — the value of labour-power falls, which directly increases surplus-value.
4. Division of labour in the workshop, and in society
There is a division of labour in society — between agriculture and industry, town and country, trade and trade — and a division within the workshop. They resemble each other, and they are opposites.
The social division arises from exchange between communities and from the differentiation of a community’s own labour; it is mediated by the sale of commodities; and it presupposes the dispersal of means of production among many independent producers.
The workshop division produces no commodity at all until the collective worker has finished; the detail worker sells nothing but his labour-power; and it presupposes the concentration of means of production in one capitalist’s hands.
Despotism inside, anarchy outside
The division of labour in the workshop implies the undisputed authority of the capitalist over men who are merely the members of a total mechanism which belongs to him. The division of labour in society brings independent producers face to face who acknowledge no authority other than that of competition — the coercion exerted by their mutual interests.
So the same bourgeois consciousness that celebrates the workshop’s planned division, its lifelong annexation of the worker to a single operation, denounces every conscious social control of production as an invasion of property and freedom. It is very characteristic that the enthusiastic apologists of the factory system have nothing more damning to urge against a general organization of the labour of society than that it would turn the whole of society into a factory.
Older societies had the one without the other
The Indian village community had a fixed social division of labour — the smith, the potter, the barber, the schoolmaster, each hereditary — and produced almost everything it needed; it went on unchanged for centuries while dynasties fell above it. The medieval guild had a social division between crafts and prevented any division within the craft, by limiting the journeymen a master could keep.
So a social division of labour can exist for millennia without the workshop division ever appearing. The division of labour in manufacture is not a natural development of the first; it is a specifically capitalist creation.
5. The capitalist character of manufacture
The collective worker belongs to capital. Manufacture develops the social productive power of labour only as a power of capital, and only by crippling the individual: it converts the worker into a crippled monstrosity by furthering his particular skill as in a forcing-house, through the suppression of a whole world of productive drives and inclinations.
And what the detail worker loses does not vanish. What is lost by the specialized workers is concentrated in the capital which confronts them. The intelligence of the process — its plan, its science — is separated from the workers and stands over them as the property of another. Begun in simple co-operation, developed in manufacture, completed by large-scale industry.
Adam Smith saw it — the detail worker becomes as stupid and ignorant as it is possible for a human being to become — and prescribed popular education in homeopathic doses. His French translator thought even that too much.
A method of relative surplus-value — and its limit
Manufacture is a particular method of producing relative surplus-value: it raises the productive power of social labour for the benefit of capital, and creates new conditions of capital’s rule over labour. It is at once historical progress and a refined and civilized means of exploitation.
But it rests on handicraft skill, and skill can refuse. The complaint of the manufacturers about the insubordination of the workers runs through the whole period. The detail worker knows his operation; capital does not; and a workforce that must be trained cannot be replaced at will. Manufacture could never seize the whole of social production — its narrow technical basis contradicted its own needs.
The transition
One of manufacture’s own products resolves the contradiction. Among the workshops it created was the workshop that made the instruments of labour themselves — tools, and then the first machines. This workshop, the product of the division of labour in manufacture, produced in its turn — machines.
Machines abolish handicraft skill as the regulating principle of production. With that the last ground on which the worker could stand against capital inside the labour process is removed, and the manufacturing period gives way to large-scale industry — Ch.15.
Workshop · Society
| in the workshop | in society | |
|---|---|---|
| what the worker sells | labour-power | a commodity |
| the product of a detail | not a commodity | a commodity |
| means of production | concentrated | dispersed |
| link between labours | the plan | exchange |
| authority | the capitalist | competition |
| Marx’s word | despotism | anarchy |
| bourgeois verdict | admirable | sacred |
A society can have the second for millennia without the first — India, the guilds. The first is capital’s invention.
Heterogeneous · Organic
| heterogeneous | organic | |
|---|---|---|
| example | the watch | the needle, paper |
| product | assembled from parts | passes through stages |
| workers | independent, often at home | a connected series |
| place | need not be one | must be one |
| pace | each his own | set by the chain |
| yields | domestic outwork | the collective worker; the law of proportion |
The organic form is manufacture proper.
The two roads into manufacture
From many crafts → one product wheelwright · harness-maker · tailor · locksmith · upholsterer ↓ gathered under one capital carriage manufacture — each craft narrowed to its carriage-part
From one craft → many operations twenty needle-makers, each making whole needles ↓ the craft decomposed needle manufacture — drawing · straightening · cutting · pointing · heading · … seventy-two hands
Opposite starting points, one result: a mechanism whose organs are people.
Real subsumption begins here. Co-operation changed the scale of the labour process; manufacture changes the process. But note what stays: the tool is in the hand, the pace is the worker’s, and the skill — narrowed though it is — still belongs to him. That residue is what Ch.15 removes.
England before the factory: the manufacturing period is Elizabeth to the early Georges.
The pores of the working day — the moments lost between tasks — are the first target of intensification, before any machine. Closing them raises output per hour without touching the hour. This is the root of every later time-and-motion study.
And the detail worker’s skill is skill in a fragment: the beginning of what the labour-process debate calls deskilling.
The collective worker (Gesamtarbeiter) is now the real producer; the individual is an organ. Two consequences worth arguing over. First, manufacture creates unskilled labour — the handicraft had none. Second, the law of proportion turns the workforce into a unit that must be bought whole: the minimum capital of Ch.11 acquires a technical reason.
The sharpest political passage in Part Four. Capital plans ruthlessly inside the factory and forbids society to plan at all. Planning is not the objection; the objection is to anyone but capital doing it. Marx turns the factory apologists’ own horror — society as a factory — back on them: they have already built one.
The separation of conception from execution. Knowledge of the whole process migrates from the workers to capital, which then confronts them with it. Babbage had already stated the economics: buy exactly the grade of skill each fragment needs and no more — the hierarchy of wages is a hierarchy of cheapening.
Ferguson, whom Smith learned from: we make a nation of helots, and have no free citizens.
Why manufacture had to give way: its foundation is the skilled hand, and the hand can be withdrawn. Ure’s complaint about the refractory hand of labour is capital’s own diagnosis. The machine is not only a productive device; it is the answer to the insubordination of the manufacturing worker. Ch.15 opens on that premise.