Capital Vol. 1, Ch. 13 — mind map
Text version — the same content in reading order
Economic Manuscripts: Capital Vol. I - Chapter Thirteen — marxists.org
Capital Vol. I : Chapter Thirteen (Co-operation)
Ch. 13 — Co-operation
The first of three chapters on how capital raises productivity. Before any division of labour, before any machine, there is the simplest change of all: many workers, one place, one capital. Marx shows that this alone creates a productive power that none of them had — and that capital gets it for nothing.
The starting point
Capitalist production begins in earnest when one capital employs a large number of workers at the same time, in the same place, on the same kind of work. At first this is only a quantitative difference from the guild master with his two or three journeymen — the same handicraft, the same tools, simply more hands in one workshop.
Marx starts here deliberately, because it is the point at which nothing technical has yet changed, and yet everything begins to.
First effect — the average becomes real
One worker is quicker, another slower; one wastes cotton, another does not. For a single small master these differences are his fortune or his ruin. But twelve workers together produce, in the aggregate, something very close to average social labour — the deviations cancel.
So the law of valorization comes fully into its own only when the individual capitalist employs many workers at once — enough for their combined labour to count as labour of average quality. The law of value works through the mass, not the individual.
Second effect — economy of constant capital
Twenty weavers in one shed need one building, not twenty; one warehouse, one set of stores, one heating system. Means of production consumed in common cost less per unit of product than the same means scattered across workshops. Part of the value transferred to each commodity falls, and with it the commodity’s value.
This cheapening costs the worker nothing and the capitalist nothing. It is a consequence of the social character of the labour — but it appears as a saving made by capital, one of its own economies.
The definition, and the new power
When numerous workers work together side by side in accordance with a plan, whether in the same process, or in different but connected processes, this form of labour is called co-operation.
The combined working day is not merely the sum of the individual days. Twelve masons together lift a stone that twelve masons separately could not lift at all. A squadron of cavalry has a force no sum of single horsemen possesses. Something is created that belongs to none of the workers singly: the social productive power of labour, and it arises from co-operation itself.
What the combined day can do
It raises mechanical force beyond any individual’s. It extends the field — a building, a drainage works, a railway cutting that no one worker could encompass. It contracts space — hands side by side, materials close. It does many things at once, or one thing from many sides. It seizes the critical moment — the harvest that must be got in within a fortnight, the flock that must be sheared before the weather turns. And it saves means of production by using them in common.
Add the animal spirits: mere social contact stimulates rivalry, and each works better in company than alone. In co-operation with others the worker strips off the fetters of his individuality and develops the capabilities of his species.
Why this power looks like capital’s
Wage-labourers cannot co-operate unless they are first assembled — hired, paid, put in one place — by the same capital. Co-operation of free workers presupposes a capital large enough to employ them. So the capitalist is not only the one who benefits from the social power of labour; he is the condition of its existence.
And because it is set in motion by capital and costs capital nothing — the worker is paid for his individual labour-power, not for the power that arises when a hundred of them combine — the social productive power of labour appears as a productive power which capital possesses by its nature, a productive power inherent in capital.
Direction, in two senses
All directly social or communal labour on a large scale requires, to a greater or lesser degree, a directing authority — a single violinist directs himself, an orchestra needs a conductor. That much is technical, and would be true of any association.
But capitalist direction is twofold. It is the co-ordination of a combined process, and it is the enforcement of a purpose the workers do not share — the extraction of the largest possible surplus. So it is despotic in form, and it grows more so as the scale grows. Capital hands the daily work of supervision to a hierarchy of foremen and managers: the non-commissioned officers and officers of an industrial army. And as the number of the co-operating workers increases, so does their resistance to the domination of capital, and with it the pressure put on by capital to overcome that resistance.
A hundred contracts, one collective worker
The capitalist buys a hundred labour-powers, but he buys them one at a time. Each worker contracts with capital singly; none contracts with the others. Their co-operation begins only in the labour process — that is, only after they have ceased to belong to themselves.
So the workers are isolated in exactly the moment that would give them strength. They enter into relations with the capitalist, but not with each other. Their unity as a collective worker exists only inside the workshop, where it is capital’s, and dissolves at the gate.
Older co-operations, and the fundamental form
Co-operation on a colossal scale is ancient — the pyramids, the irrigation works of Egypt and India, the temples — but it rested on direct domination: slavery, or the state as landlord. The village community and the guild co-operated too, on the basis of common property or of the master’s craft.
Capitalist co-operation is different in its precondition: the free wage-labourer of Ch.6, selling labour-power to capital. Beyond that it is at first only a quantitative extension of the handicraft. Yet it is the germ of everything that follows: simple co-operation remains the fundamental form of the capitalist mode of production, present inside manufacture and inside the factory, and surviving alongside them wherever capital works on a large scale without transforming the labour process itself.
The two faces of management
| co-ordination | despotism | |
|---|---|---|
| arises from | the combined process | the antagonism |
| present in | any large-scale labour | capitalist labour only |
| image | the conductor | the officer |
| who does it | the capitalist, at first | delegated to a hierarchy |
| grows with | complexity | numbers, and resistance |
Capital’s supervision is both at once, and passes the one off as the other.
What co-operation achieves — Marx’s list
- mechanical force — twelve masons, one stone
- field of action — canals, embankments, railways
- space — hands side by side, materials to hand
- simultaneity — many hands on one object at once
- critical moments — the harvest, the shearing
- economy of means — one shed, one store, one fire
- animal spirits — rivalry and emulation in company
All gratis to capital. The worker is paid as one; the power is that of many.
Three forms of relative surplus-value — Part Four
| Ch.13 co-operation | Ch.14 manufacture | Ch.15 machinery | |
|---|---|---|---|
| what changes | scale | division of labour | instrument |
| the craft | intact | split into details | abolished |
| the worker | one of many | a detail worker | a machine-minder |
| subsumption | formal → | real begins | real complete |
| power appropriated | of the crowd | of the organised whole | of science and nature |
Each is the social productive power of labour appearing as a power of capital.
Why the average matters. Ch.1 said value is socially necessary labour-time; here is the mechanism by which the individual capital comes to embody it. Below a certain size the law of value is a lottery for the producer; above it, a law. This also picks up the minimum capital of Ch.11.
Not yet Adam Smith’s pin factory — that is division of labour, and Ch.14.
Not merely the sum. The social productive power of labour is the key concept of Part Four, and it is emergent — a property of the combination, not of the parts. Ch.13 is that power in its barest form; Ch.14 adds division of labour, Ch.15 adds machinery. In each case the same thing happens: a power of social labour is appropriated as a power of capital.
The fetish moves into production. In Ch.1 the social character of labour appeared as a property of things; here the social power of co-operating labour appears as a property of capital. Same inversion, new site — and this time it is not only an appearance but a fact of ownership, since the combination really is assembled by capital.
Twofold management is the distinction the whole later labour-process debate rests on — Braverman rebuilt Labor and Monopoly Capital on it. Co-ordination is necessary in any large-scale labour; despotism is specific to labour done for someone else’s surplus. The orchestra needs its conductor in a free association too. What it does not need is a foreman.
The double freedom of Ch.6 seen from inside the workshop. Each worker is free to contract, and contracts alone. The collective worker — the only one with real power — is assembled by capital and belongs to it. Trade unionism is, in these terms, the attempt to make the combination exist outside the gate, on the workers’ own account.
Two things to hold. First, large-scale co-operation before capital rested on unfree labour; capital’s novelty is co-operation among the doubly free. Second, simple co-operation is where formal subsumption begins to become real: the labour process is still the old handicraft, but its scale is already capital’s doing. Ch.14 changes the process itself.