Capital Vol. 1, Ch. 12 — mind map
Text version — the same content in reading order
Economic Manuscripts: Capital Vol. I - Chapter Twelve — marxists.org
Capital Vol. I : Chapter Twelve (The Concept of Relative Surplus-Value)
Part Four: The Production of Relative Surplus-Value
Ch. 12 — The Concept of Relative Surplus-Value
Ch.10 fixed the end of the day by law. Ch.11 showed the rate cannot be raised past 24 hours. So if the day cannot grow, how can the surplus? By moving the other boundary — the point where the worker stops working for himself.
The line a — b — c
Picture the working day as a line. From a to b is necessary labour, say ten hours; from b to c is surplus labour, say two. Part Three lengthened the day by pushing c outward with b fixed.
Now take a–c as given — the day is of a definite length, and can be assumed fixed. Surplus labour b–c can then only be extended in one way: by shifting b back toward a. The day stays twelve hours; necessary labour shrinks; the surplus grows by exactly what necessary labour loses.
Not by cutting wages
One route is obvious and Marx sets it aside: pay the worker less than the value of his labour-power. It happens constantly in practice — he says so, and says it matters — but it violates the standing assumption that commodities exchange at their value, and so cannot be the theoretical case.
So the question stands in its strict form. With labour-power sold at its value, necessary labour-time can fall only if the value of labour-power itself falls — that is, only if less labour-time is needed to produce the means of subsistence the worker lives on.
Productivity, and in which branches
That requires a rise in the productivity of labour. By an increase in the productivity of labour we mean an alteration in the labour process of such a kind as to shorten the labour-time socially necessary for the production of a commodity — a revolution in the technical and social conditions of the process, in the mode of production itself.
But not just anywhere. Only productivity in the branches that produce the worker’s means of subsistence, or the means of production for those branches, lowers the value of labour-power. A revolution in the making of luxuries leaves necessary labour untouched. The sum of what the worker consumes is what counts.
The two definitions
The surplus-value produced by prolongation of the working day I call absolute surplus-value.
The surplus-value arising from the curtailment of the necessary labour-time, and from the corresponding alteration in the respective lengths of the two components of the working day, I call relative surplus-value.
The same ratio, moved by different ends: one by lengthening the whole, the other by shrinking the paid part.
But no capitalist aims at any of this — the mechanism
The individual capitalist does not set out to cheapen labour-power. What moves him is extra surplus-value. Suppose he introduces a method that doubles his productivity: twelve hours now yield 24 articles instead of 12. The individual value of each falls to 9d, while the social value — set by the normal conditions of the trade — is still a shilling.
He sells at, say, 10d: below social value, so as to clear a doubled output, yet above his own. On every article he pockets a penny that other capitalists cannot. His labour counts, for the moment, as intensified labour — creating more value in twelve hours than average labour of the same kind. Necessary labour falls from ten hours to seven and a half, surplus rises from two to four and a half, in his mill alone.
The extra surplus-value dies — and does its work in dying
The advantage lasts only until the method becomes general. Competition — the coercive law of competition — forces rivals to adopt it; the social value sinks to the new individual value; the penny disappears.
What remains is the commodity, permanently cheaper. And if that commodity enters the worker’s consumption, or into the means of production of what he consumes, the value of labour-power has fallen and necessary labour with it. The private pursuit of a temporary premium has produced, behind everyone’s back, a permanent rise in relative surplus-value for the whole class of capitalists.
The immanent drive
Hence there is immanent in capital an inclination and constant tendency to heighten the productivity of labour, in order to cheapen commodities and, by cheapening commodities, to cheapen the worker himself.
The value of a commodity varies inversely with productivity. So does the value of labour-power, because it is made of commodities. Relative surplus-value varies directly with it. The same movement that fills the shops cheapens the man who fills them.
The closing paradox
The object of raising productivity under capital is not to shorten the working day. It is to shorten the part of the day the worker works for himself, in order to lengthen the part he works for nothing.
The shortening of the working day is therefore by no means what is aimed at in capitalist production, when labour is economised by increasing its productivity. Every saving of labour is a saving for capital: the economised hours are not returned to the worker but converted into surplus labour. How far that can go, when the day itself is no longer at issue, is the subject of the next three chapters.
The innovator’s premium
Before — 12 h · 12 articles means of production 6d + new value 6d = 1s each new value 6s = wages 5s + surplus 1s necessary 10 h · surplus 2 h
After — 12 h · 24 articles individual value 9d · social value still 1s sells at 10d → 20s for 24 less 12s means of production = 8s new value = wages 5s + surplus 3s necessary 7½ h · surplus 4½ h
The penny per article is extra surplus-value. It lasts until the trade catches up.
Absolute · Relative
| absolute | relative | |
|---|---|---|
| what moves | length of day | necessary labour |
| how | prolong the day | raise productivity |
| limit | 24 h; law; the body | none in principle |
| needs | control of workers | transforming the labour process |
| subsumption | formal | real |
| era | Part Three | Part Four |
Both are the same surplus labour / necessary labour ratio.
Two ways to grow the surplus
a ────────── b ── c
necessary 10 h · surplus 2 h
Absolute — push c outward
a ────────── b ──── c′
necessary 10 h · surplus 4 h · day 14 h
Relative — pull b inward
a ─────── b′ ───── c
necessary 7½ h · surplus 4½ h · day 12 h
Same ratio moved, different boundary. Ch.10 capped c; Part Four is the story of b.
Part Four in a single geometric move. Part Three was about the position of c; Part Four is about the position of b. Nothing else changes — same day, same worker, same law of value — and yet the whole technical history of capitalism follows from it.
Which branches matter is not a detail. The value of labour-power is the value of the wage basket, so only cheaper bread, cloth, housing, fuel — or cheaper inputs to them — reduce necessary labour. Productivity in yachts does nothing; nor, notably, in armaments. Keep this for the debates over unproductive labour later.
Extra surplus-value is the mediation — the same shape as Ch.2. Private agents pursue private ends and a social result appears that none of them intended. The individual capitalist is the bearer of the process, not its author. This is why Marx can say capital has a tendency without any capitalist having a plan.
The coercive law of competition explains innovation without innovators. A capitalist who does not adopt the new method is undersold; one who does gains nothing lasting. Everyone runs to stand still. And it locates the drive for productivity in the relation, not in technology or human ingenuity as such.
Note what this does not say. The value of labour-power falls, but the wage in use-values can rise at the same time — more and better goods for fewer hours of value. Relative surplus-value is compatible with rising living standards. The worker gets more things while a larger share of his day goes to capital. Read this against any simple immiseration story.
The productivity paradox, stated in 1867. Every gain in productivity could shorten the day; under capital none does, because the saved time belongs to whoever owns the process. This is the structural answer to why the fifteen-hour week never arrived — and a good place to bring the room back to the present.