Capital Vol. 1, Ch. 11 — mind map

drag to pan · scroll to zoom
Loading mind map…
Text version — the same content in reading order

Economic Manuscripts: Capital Vol. I - Chapter Eleven — marxists.org

Capital Vol. I : Chapter Eleven (Rate and Mass of surplus-value)


Ch. 11 — The Rate and Mass of Surplus-Value

The close of Part Three. Ch.9 gave the rate, Ch.10 the length. Ch.11 asks after the mass — how much surplus-value a given capital actually commands — and finds a hard ceiling that the rate alone can never get past.


The standing assumption

Throughout, the value of labour-power is given and constant. A definite quantity of labour-time, say six hours, is needed to reproduce the worker; the working day is of a definite length; and every worker employed is average.

On that footing the argument is simple arithmetic — and Marx wants it simple, because the conclusions are meant to hold whatever the technical conditions of production happen to be.


The first law — the mass of surplus-value

Marx writes it two ways, and the pair is the point.

S = (s / v) × V S = P × (a′ / a) × n

where S is the mass of surplus-value, V the variable capital advanced, P the value of one average labour-power, a′/a surplus labour over necessary labour (the degree of exploitation), and n the number of workers employed. Since V = P × n and s/v = a′/a, the two lines say the same thing.

The first form: mass equals variable capital times the rate. The second form spells out what variable capital is — so many workers at so much each — and so shows the mass as a compound ratio of how many labour-powers are exploited at once and how hard each is worked. Two factors, and only two.

Constant capital does not enter. Machinery and cotton may be vast or trifling; they change nothing in this equation.


The second law — compensation, within a limit

A fall in the number of workers can be made good by a rise in the rate. Halve the workforce and double the surplus labour of each, and the mass of surplus-value is unchanged. Capital behaves accordingly: it is indifferent between employing many workers lightly and few workers hard.

So far the two factors look freely substitutable, and to the capitalist they appear so.


…and the limit is absolute

They are not freely substitutable, because the two factors are not of the same kind. The rate can in principle be driven upward; the day cannot be driven past 24 hours — and in practice stops far short of it, at the physical and moral limits of Ch.10.

So the surplus labour extractable from one worker has a ceiling, and the total mass has a ceiling of n × 24 hours however the rate is raised. The absolute limit of the working day sets an absolute limit to the compensation for a reduced variable capital by a raised rate of surplus-value.

A capital cannot shed workers without limit and make it up by intensity. Living labour is the substance of surplus-value, and there is only so much of it in a person and a day.


The third law — and a contradiction deferred

With the value and the degree of exploitation of labour-power given, the masses of value and surplus-value produced by different capitals vary directly as the size of their variable components. A capital that is mostly wages produces far more surplus-value than an equal capital that is mostly machinery.

Marx then states the objection himself: this contradicts all experience based on appearances. Equal capitals in different trades notoriously yield roughly equal profits, whatever their composition. He does not resolve it here. The resolution needs many intermediate links, and is held over to Volume III.


How much money must a man have to be a capitalist?

A definite minimum. He must command enough variable capital that the surplus of his workers frees him from working himself, and then keeps him.

Marx’s illustration, at a rate of 50 %: each worker yields half a wage in surplus. To live merely as well as one of his own workers, the master must employ two. To live twice as well and turn half the surplus back into capital, he must set eight in motion. Below that he is a small master who still works alongside his men — a better-off artisan, not a capitalist.

He is a capitalist only in so far as the minimum sum advanced greatly exceeds the medieval maximum.


Hegel, cited by name

Here, as in natural science, is verified the correctness of the law discovered by Hegel in his Logic, that merely quantitative changes beyond a certain point pass into qualitative differences.

More money is at first only more money. Past the threshold it is no longer a larger purse but a different social relation: its owner stops labouring and starts commanding, and the sum becomes capital.


What capital has done so far — and has not

Capital, at this stage, takes the labour process as it finds it. It lengthens the day, it gathers more workers under one roof, it supervises — but it has not yet altered the technical mode of production. The handicraft is still a handicraft; the tools are the old tools.

This is what Marx names the formal subsumption of labour under capital. The relation of command is new; the work itself is not. Two things do change: the labour process becomes the process of consuming labour-power by the capitalist, and capital develops into a coercive relation which compels the working class to do more work than the narrow round of its own needs would require.


How Part Three closes

Capital has developed into command over labour — over the worker himself — and into a coercive relation that forces the working class to do more work than the narrow round of its own needs requires. As the producer of the activity of others, as the extractor of surplus labour and the exploiter of labour-power, it surpasses in energy, disregard of bounds, recklessness and efficiency, all earlier systems of production based on directly compulsory labour.

But so far capital has subordinated labour on the technical basis it found ready-made. The surplus-value won by prolonging the day appeared independent of any change in the mode of production. The question now turns over: how does capital change production itself? That is Part Four.


The threshold of capital

Marx’s illustration, rate of surplus-value 50 % — each worker yields half a wage as surplus.

workerssurpluswhat it buys
21 wageto live like a worker
84 wagesto live twice as well and accumulate half

Below the threshold the master still works beside his men. Above it he does not work at all.

Quantity has become quality.


Why fewer workers cannot be made up

Day 12 h · necessary 6 · surplus 6 · rate 100 %

100 workers → 600 surplus hours a day

50 workers → need 12 surplus hrs each → an 18-hour day. Rate 200 %. Brutal, but possible.

25 workers → need 24 surplus hrs each → a 30-hour day. Impossible.

Even driving necessary labour to zero — the worker paid nothing, which cannot happen — 25 workers yield at most 25 × 24 = 600 hrs, i.e. every hour of every day unpaid.

Ceiling: S ≤ n × 24 hours.


The three laws

I. S = (s/v) × V S = P × (a′/a) × n mass = rate × variable capital; or value of one labour-power × degree of exploitation × number of workers. Same thing, since V = P·n and s/v = a′/a. Two factors only: how many, how hard.

II. fewer workers ↔ higher rate — but the day stops at 24 h, so compensation has an absolute limit.

III. rate and wage given → masses vary as the variable part. Contradicts appearances; resolution deferred to Vol. III.

Throughout: the value of labour-power is held constant.


Note what has dropped out. The whole of constant capital is absent from S = (s/v) × V. That is Ch.8’s distinction doing its work: only the variable part valorizes, so only the variable part can appear in the mass.

This is also why Marx insisted on s/v rather than the rate of profit back in Ch.9.


The asymmetry is the point of the chapter. Workers can be multiplied; hours cannot. Capital can always hire another hand, but it cannot buy a 25th hour.

So the two factors of the mass are not interchangeable after all, and absolute surplus-value runs into a wall. When the day is capped by law (Ch.10), the only remaining road is to shrink necessary labour instead — which is relative surplus-value, and Part Four.


Marx raises the objection against himself rather than waiting to be caught — the same move as the Ch.5 contradiction. Worth flagging in a session: this is the transformation problem announced twenty years before it is addressed, and the honest admission that the law of value does not read straight off prices and profits.

His analogy: apparent motions and real motions. You need a theory to see why the appearance is what it is.


A threshold, not a spectrum. The distinction between capitalist and worker is not that one has more and the other less; it is that beyond a certain sum the owner stops working. Class is a quantity that has become a quality.

And it is historically dated — the medieval guild maximum kept masters below the threshold on purpose.


Formal vs. real subsumption — the hinge out of Part Three. Formal: capital takes over an existing labour process and squeezes it by duration. Real: capital remakes the labour process in its own image — co-operation, division of labour, machinery — and squeezes it by productivity.

Chs. 13–15 are that story. The distinction is not in the chapter titles, which is why it is easy to miss.


Capital out-does slavery and the corvée at extraction because its compulsion is indirect and boundless: no master watches a single slave the way the market watches every capitalist. The comparison is not rhetorical — Marx means it as a measure.

One correction worth noting: the famous line answering Adam Smith (command over unpaid labour) belongs to the close of Ch.18, not here. See the Chapters 16–18 canvas.