Latin American Cinema

When I first moved to Kent, for a few years I ran a world cinema club in our village hall. So few people in a largish space! But many who came were lovely and sometimes amazed - I particularly remember an obviously cultured Iranian woman living in an adjacent village astounded to watch a movie in her own language in the primordial swamp around Ashford.

The cinema club probably started out of attending the Italian film fest in London for several years in the wake of new Neapolitan cinema.

On the latin film tip, I remember showing Familia Rodante and Bombón: El Perro which went down a storm. Both are Argentine, both from 2004: a grandmother dragging her whole family north to a wedding in a 1956 Chevrolet converted into a camper, and a man laid off from a Patagonian petrol station whose luck turns when someone pays him with a pedigree dog.

When I was much younger I did a course on Latin American magical realist writers: Borges, Julio Cortázar, Isabel Allende, Gabriel García Márquez (Love in the Time of Cholera), Paulo Coelho, Carlos Fuentes’s Terra Nostra and Alejo Carpentier’s Concierto barroco.

The one that stuck was Concierto barroco: a rich Mexican and his Cuban servant travel to Venice and sit through Vivaldi’s opera about Montezuma, watching Europe get the conquest of Mexico wrong and set it to music. Western historical hegemony (or something like that!): who gets to tell the story of the Americas, and the pleasure of answering back.

So I arrived with two ideas of what Latin America was for. One was magic, from the course. The other was politics, and in the past few years most of the films I have watched from there have supplied it. There is an overarching sense of colonial history and its contemporary ripples in US-backed interference and the neoliberalism that came in behind it.

It starts with the colony itself. In Lucrecia Martel’s Zama a functionary of the Spanish crown rots at a river outpost in the 1790s, waiting for a transfer that never comes. In Felipe Gálvez’s Los colonos a landowner in Tierra del Fuego in 1901 sends three riders to open a route to the sea, which means clearing the Selk’nam, and a few years later the state turns up to tidy the story. Glauber Rocha’s Black God, White Devil plays like a French new wave film, but the characters are real - a potted history with a small cast, more appreciated after the viewing.

Then the coups. Pablo Larraín made three films about Pinochet’s Chile, and the last of them, No, is the one that stays with me as an argument: the dictator is beaten in the 1988 plebiscite, but by an advertising man, selling democracy like a soft drink in the language of the market the regime brought in. Patricio Guzmán’s Nostalgia for the Light puts astronomers on the mountaintops of the Atacama and, below them, the women still combing the same desert for the remains of the disappeared.

And Bacurau says the whole thing out loud. A village in the Brazilian backlands drops off the online maps, the phone signal goes, and a party of mostly American tourists arrives who have paid to hunt the inhabitants, with a local politician holding the door.

Aside from Bacurau, those films were an education that fleshed out an entire continent for me.

But the films I love are the ones that do none of this. El Pampero Cine is a Buenos Aires collective (Mariano Llinás, Laura Citarella, Alejo Moguillansky and Agustín Mendilaharzu) who have worked since 2002 with a deliberate independence from the usual sources of film funding, the same faces turning up in each other’s work. I watched La Flor after watching Peter Watkins’s long anti-nuclear film The Journey, surprised that some familiar Latin names had tried something longer. It runs thirteen and a half hours: four stories that start and never finish, a fifth that is complete, and a sixth that has no beginning, only an end. La mujer de los perros is almost wordless, a woman and her pack of dogs in a shack on the edge of the city through four seasons. These films take perhaps mundane themes and take them in unexpected and complex directions, often transcendent. They are closer to Borges and Cortázar, stories inside stories and games with the audience, than to Larraín or Guzmán.

Diagram of the structure of La Flor: four arrows curving upward from a single point, a small closed loop beneath them, and one arrow pointing straight down
The flower: Llinás's diagram of La Flor. Four stories that begin and don't end, one that loops closed, and one that only ends. (Drawing by hinnk, Wikimedia Commons, CC0, after El Pampero Cine.)

La Flor I watched in chunks. The first two chapters would make great standalone films, but then it meanders into themes like the inability of film to capture the beauty of nature (at length!). It discusses its own making literally and metaphorically.

El escarabajo de oro is the pivot. A European co-production arrives in Buenos Aires to make a worthy biopic of a 19th-century Swedish feminist writer. The Argentine crew counter with an equally worthy political subject of their own, and use both as cover to go treasure hunting in Misiones, by way of Poe and Stevenson. It is more or less Concierto barroco with a film crew.

And it showed me my own two ideas from the outside. Magic and politics are the two things Europe expects Latin America to deliver, and the film is about that transaction: who pays, and what they think they are buying. What it implies is something else, the right not to be representative. To play, to help yourself to Poe and Stevenson without asking. Borges argued as much in “The Argentine Writer and Tradition”: the whole of Western culture is theirs to use, irreverently, and nobody is owed local colour.

One other figure looms large: Ivan Illich, who based himself in Cuernavaca from 1961 and relentlessly critiqued the Western sense of Latin America as a place to be helped. His centre there was set up to train North American missionaries and spent much of its energy talking them out of it; in 1968 he told a room of American student volunteers, in a talk called “To Hell with Good Intentions”, to come to Mexico to look and to study but not to help. The superiority he was after was the kind that arrives meaning well.

That is a third thing the West wants from Latin America, after magic and suffering: somewhere to improve. Illich also supplies the join in my overarching theme, between the colony and the market. The mission never stopped. The missionary became the development expert, and the development expert became the economist. El baño del Papa is close to one of his parables: a poor Uruguayan border town in 1988 bets everything it has on the crowds promised for a papal visit, and a bicycle smuggler decides the money is in building a pay toilet.

He has a word for what Pampero do, too: conviviality, making things with friends and with tools you control. It makes sense of films I had filed elsewhere. The woman with the dogs is living outside the economy altogether, and the bank clerk in Los delincuentes, who steals exactly the salary he would have earned by retirement and takes three and a half years in prison over twenty-five at the counter, is doing Illich’s arithmetic on wage labour.

Which leaves the viewer. Nearly everything here reached me through festivals and streaming, and a fair few were made with European money. It is a European’s list. The films about the coups were not made for me, though; Guzmán’s women were in that desert long before anyone pointed a camera at them. “Come to look, don’t come to help” is not a bad rule for watching them, and looking back it is all the village hall ever was. My best memory of it is still the Iranian woman, hearing her own language on a council estate built on bogland that a landowner sold to the council in contempt of his poorer neighbours.

Also watched

Mentioned above: Familia rodante (Pablo Trapero, 2004), Bombón: El Perro (Carlos Sorín, 2004), Zama (Lucrecia Martel, 2017), Los colonos / The Settlers (Felipe Gálvez, 2023), Deus e o Diabo na Terra do Sol / Black God, White Devil (Glauber Rocha, 1964), No (Pablo Larraín, 2012), Nostalgia de la luz / Nostalgia for the Light (Patricio Guzmán, 2010), Bacurau (Kleber Mendonça Filho and Juliano Dornelles, 2019), La Flor (Mariano Llinás, 2018), La mujer de los perros / Dog Lady (Laura Citarella and Verónica Llinás, 2015), El escarabajo de oro / The Gold Bug (Alejo Moguillansky and Fia-Stina Sandlund, 2014), Los delincuentes / The Delinquents (Rodrigo Moreno, 2023), El baño del Papa / The Pope’s Toilet (César Charlone and Enrique Fernández, 2007).


A special mention

In 2001 I went to Mexico with the Gyalwang Drukpa, to Cuernavaca. I would never have gone there, and he didn’t know why he was in what seemed like a tourist resort (he was leading a retreat for local practitioners). Our host booked me into a hotel in Mexico City, “the room that we put Carlos Castaneda in”, where I had strange violent dreams. In the lobby, the receptionist paged “Gavin Erickson”, and thus I met an American version of me. I didn’t know it was Illich’s town at the time. It is how I discovered him later, by wondering if anything interesting had ever happened there. Magic.